Image from Bon Appetit
Much to my delight, this month’s Bon Appetit has an amazing article on my all-time favorite food: Pumpkin! Check it out for more info and some inspiring recipes. The beauty of pumpkin is that it goes well with sweet (pumpkin pie, naturally) like molasses, sugar, brown sugar, and cream. It also pairs nicely with seemingly unusual combinations of vegetables and spices: try mushrooms, scallions, leeks and spices like chili powder, mustard, cilantro, or thyme. My favorite way to prepare pumpkin is with something bold, like lots of ginger or bleu cheese. it has such a creamy soft texture and subtle flavor, so the dish changes dramatically depending on what you add!
Oct/Nov are my favorite months solely because of 1. Fresh Pumpkin in the stores and 2. Thanksgiving. The following Venn diagram illustrates my most ultimate happy moment:
For Everything Else, There's Mastercard.
But seriously. I think a lot of people are daunted by the idea of cooking pumpkin. Truth be told, it takes a little work on the front end, but is totally worth it and a lot of the preparation for cooking pumpkin can be done ahead of time.
What to Look For
If you are cooking pumpkin, buy a sugar pumpkin (also known as pie pumpkin or sweet pumpkin). Bon Appetit says “Look for a pumpkin that’s smaller and rounder with less defined ridges than jack-o’-lantern pumpkins. Choose firm ones that feel heavy for their size and have dull, not glossy, skin.” I like pumpkins that are roughly the size of a small watermelon or a honeydew melon; one of these is the perfect size for a soup or a pair of pies. In addition, this smaller size makes them easier to handle with a knife, peeler, and spoon.
Dismantling a Pumpkin
First, make a horizontal cut to take off the stem and top of the pumpkin. Make a second cut parallel to this to take off the bottom, just enough to get rid of the uneven surface. Now stand the pumpkin up on its newly flattened bottom. Make one vertical cut to divide it exactly in half. Using a spoon, scoop out the stringy insides and seeds. I find it easiest to take off a very thin layer of the actual pumpkin flesh to ensure that the part you use will be smooth and string-free. Be sure to set aside the seeds for use later! If dicing the pumpkin, use a vegetable peeler to remove the skin – this is where getting a SMOOTH pumpkin comes in handy. If leaving the pumpkin in large pieces for roasting, do not remove skin. Lastly, cut the pumpkin into 1 inch strips and from there 1 inch cubes. You are now ready to make somethin’!
For Roasting
You should have two skin-on pumpkin halves. Cut each of these vertically in half so you now have 4 pumpkin wedges. The easiest way to roast a pumpkin is to brush the exposed flesh with olive oil, place skin down on a baking sheet, and pop into a 350 degree oven until browned and softened. Top with cream, brown sugar, ginger, or salt and chili powder, and enjoy with a spoon!
For Pies, Soups, and Recipes Calling for Pumpkin Puree
Take the cubed pumpkin and place into boiling water, probably around 10 minutes depending on how thick you cut your cubes. You know they are ready if a fork slides effortlessly into a cube. The texture should be something like a baked potato – soft so it can be mashed but not overcooked into a gooey sloppy mess. It will not have the bright orange color you see in canned pumpkin, it will look like a bright goldenrod or dandelion color. Pour over a colander to drain the water from the pumpkin pieces. Transfer to a bowl. Using a fork or potato masher, mash the pumpkin until it is smooth. The pumpkin puree can be kept in the fridge in an airtight container for several days. I recommend making a 2-3 pumpkin batch of puree and freezing into 2 cup portions. A can of pumpkin is 15 oz. which is slightly less than 2 cups, so it is safe to assume that most recipes will call for pumpkin in 2 cup increments. Now, when you want to make a pie, you have pumpkin already made in the freezer!
Sauteed Pumpkin
A third way to prepare pumpkin is to sautee it. In order to cook it in a reasonable amount of time, you will want to slice it smaller, say 1/2 inch cubes or 1/4 inch thick scallops. You can store raw diced pumpkin in an airtight container for several days in the fridge. When you are ready to prepare it, throw some in a hot skillet with butter or olive oil and add desired seasonings. Pumpkin is very tasty when browned on all sides in a frying pan – just add a couple tablespoons of water and cover towards the end of cooking to be sure the inside cooks through. Again, you can add either sweet or savory spice, and something nice like mushrooms, thyme, or cilantro.